NYC FC vs. Atlanta United FC: Match Prediction & Pick
Griffin Wong Previews Thursday’s Major League Soccer Match: New York City FC vs. Atlanta United FC
Setting the Stage
With the inaugural 32-team FIFA Club World Cup about to unfold in Miami this weekend, all eyes will be on the United States as they prepare to host some of the world’s most elite clubs. Amidst this global soccer spotlight, Major League Soccer (MLS) will hold its own, albeit quietly, with a limited schedule including a match tonight between New York City FC (NYCFC) and Atlanta United FC. This clash is set to kick off at Yankee Stadium at 8:30 p.m. and features NYCFC as a narrow favorite at -110 odds, with Atlanta listed at +260 and a draw at +255.
Recent Performance
Despite being previous champions—NYCFC lifting the MLS Cup in 2021 and Atlanta United claiming it in 2019—both teams have stumbled out of the gate in 2025. Currently, NYCFC occupies the 10th spot in the Eastern Conference, while Atlanta finds itself languishing in 13th place. The Five Stripes have seen the return of Paraguayan forward Miguel Almirón from Newcastle United, but his presence hasn’t registered statistically, as he has only four goal contributions across 16 appearances. In what is undoubtedly a setback for Atlanta, Almirón is unavailable for tonight’s match due to international commitments.
Offensive Struggles
Offensively, both teams are facing challenges with their attacking units. NYCFC ranks as one of the least prolific teams in the Eastern Conference, having managed to score just enough to find themselves among the bottom tier. Atlanta, while slightly better in this regard, is still near the bottom, indicating a struggle to convert chances into goals. The Pigeons have found the net the fifth least times in the conference, while Atlanta sits just one position higher.
Defensive Concerns
Where the two teams diverge significantly is in their defensive performances. NYCFC boasts a commendable defensive record, having conceded just 20 goals in 17 matches—the fourth-fewest in the Eastern Conference. In stark contrast, Atlanta’s defense has faltered, allowing 30 goals—the third most in the league. The troubling form of goalkeeper Brad Guzan is a central factor; he has let in 30 goals against an expected goals (xG) tally of just 25.1, marking one of the worst performances by a goalkeeper this season. At the other end, Matt Freese of NYCFC has excelled, ranking as one of the league’s top goalkeepers by the same xG measure.
Formations and Strategies
In response to their woes, Atlanta has shifted to more defensive formations, implementing five defenders in four of their last six matches. This change has yielded some improvement; they have conceded only two goals in two matches. However, their personnel simply don’t match the caliber required for a top-tier defensive unit. Key defenders like Luis Abram and Matthew Edwards have struggled statistically, ranking low in tackles and interceptions. Abram will also miss the match, further weakening their defensive line.
Missing Key Players
Both teams will be missing influential players due to international duty, affecting their potential for offensive impact. NYCFC’s Hannes Wolf has been a bright spot lately with three goals in three matches, but his ability to self-create is limited when compared to teammate Alonso Martínez, who won’t feature for the Pigeons. On the flip side, Atlanta’s Emmanuel Latte Lath could be the wild card. Despite a scoring drought, he has shown promise in the past, particularly against NYCFC, where he managed to score and assist in their last encounter.
Squad Value Dynamics
Another crucial aspect to consider is the financial valuation of the players. Atlanta’s combined squad market value is approximately one and a half times greater than that of NYCFC, which could tilt the balance in terms of depth and quality on the pitch. Notably, Latte Lath ranks as the most valuable player in the match, having scored 11 goals in the EFL Championship the previous season.
Best Bet Outlook
Given the uneven form and continued struggles both teams face, the best bet for tonight’s match could be tied to a draw or an Atlanta United victory at -120 odds. This bet acknowledges both the potential for a competitive encounter and the fact that both teams are looking to turn their fortunes around.
For more soccer insights, check out BBC Sport.
