USMNT Transfers: Grading Key Moves Before 2026 World Cup

The January transfer window has come to a close, and while some leagues are still active with moves, the major European leagues have wrapped up their business. This winter has proven particularly eventful for American players, with a mix of transfers within Major League Soccer (MLS) and moves abroad, particularly to the Bundesliga. Notably, players like James Sands and John Tolkin have made strides in Europe, while young talents such as Caleb Wiley have sought opportunities to showcase their skills on loan. Let’s dive into the details of these moves and their potential impact ahead of a pivotal year for U.S. soccer.

Caleb Wiley: A Loan to Watford

Caleb Wiley’s transition from Atlanta United to Chelsea seemed promising, but after struggling to find playing time at Strasbourg—with just six appearances in Ligue 1—the 20-year-old right back has moved on loan to Watford. This loan deal comes at a crucial moment; Watford, only three points away from a promotion playoff spot in the Championship, will look to Wiley to bolster their defense. This environment promises more match minutes, which are essential for his development as he aims to solidify his place in the U.S. Men’s National Team (USMNT). Grade: B

Jack McGlynn: A Big Move to Houston Dynamo

After an impressive January camp with the USMNT, Jack McGlynn’s transfer from Philadelphia Union to Houston Dynamo raised some eyebrows. The attacking midfielder has found a more fitting home at Dynamo, who paid a substantial $2.1 million in an unprecedented cash-for-player exchange within MLS. Reporting to new head coach Ben Olsen, he has the chance to replace veteran players like Hector Herrera. If he can adapt quickly, this move could serve as a launchpad for a future European transfer. Grade: C

Luca De La Torre: Embracing a New Challenge in San Diego

Luca De La Torre’s transfer from Celta Vigo to San Diego FC on loan signifies a strategic risk. After a rising profile in La Liga, he found it difficult to secure regular playing time. The move to San Diego under head coach Mikey Varas—a familiar face from the USMNT setup—provides De La Torre with a platform to showcase his talent. With a purchase option in place, this opportunity allows him to prove his mettle closer to home, keeping him in the conversation for a national team spot as the 2026 World Cup approaches. Grade: B

John Tolkin: Taking a Risk with Holstein Kiel

John Tolkin’s move from New York Red Bulls to Holstein Kiel in the Bundesliga carries both promise and risk. The 22-year-old defender will join a team battling relegation, where he will need to make an immediate impact. This opportunity allows him to demonstrate his skills against tougher competition while vying for a starting position in one of the world’s top leagues. With his ambition to become a USMNT regular, this move is crucial for his career trajectory. Grade: A

Jesus Ferreira: From FC Dallas to Seattle Sounders

Jesus Ferreira’s transfer from FC Dallas to the Seattle Sounders comes with some expectation. Slotting in as a full-time striker to replace Jordan Morris, Ferreira aims to make an impression following his involvement in January camp. This move, while a step in the right direction post-nearly transferring to Russia, raises questions about Ferreira’s potential for an even bigger opportunity abroad. He has a chance to revitalize his career back into the national team conversation. Grade: C+

Brandon Vazquez: Returning to MLS with Austin FC

After a stint at Monterrey, where he struggled for playing time, Brandon Vazquez’s return to the MLS with Austin FC presents a fresh start. He is set to become the focal point of an attacking line that might soon lose stars like Sebastian Driussi. This move is crucial for Vazquez as he aims to solidify his presence with the USMNT, especially when competition at the striker position remains fierce. With opportunities to showcase his skills, it’s a pivotal moment for him. Grade: B

James Sands: A Chance for Redemption at FC St. Pauli

James Sands is embarking on a loan spell from New York City FC to FC St. Pauli in the second tier of German football. Having previously struggled for regular minutes during his time at Rangers, this new opportunity places him directly in a pressure-filled environment crucial for his growth. For the 24-year-old, success in this context could pave the way for a more established role in European soccer and bolster his claims for national team selection. Grade: C

For more in-depth analysis and coverage of the January transfer window, check out BBC Sport’s dedicated coverage on football transfers to stay informed on shifting rosters and player movements.